Should I use a dog harness or collar when walking my dog?
Jan 27, 2023
One major benefit of using a dog harness is that it distributes pressure more evenly across the dog's chest and shoulders, rather than just the neck, as is the case with a collar. This can help to prevent injury to the trachea and other sensitive neck structures, as well as reduce the risk of injury from pulling or sudden jerks.
Another benefit of a harness is that it can provide added control when walking or training a dog, as it allows you to attach a leash to the front of the chest, rather than the back. This can help to steer the dog and discourage pulling, which can be especially helpful for dogs that are strong or easily excited.
A harness can also be useful for dogs with certain medical conditions, such as spinal or neck issues, which may make it uncomfortable or unsafe to use a collar.
On the other hand, some disadvantages of using a harness include that it may be harder to put on and take off, and that it can be more difficult to properly fit, as it has more straps to adjust. Some dogs may also find it uncomfortable or restrictive, and may try to scratch or rub at it.
Overall, a harness can be a great option for many dogs, particularly those that pull or have certain health issues. However, it's important to choose a well-fitting harness, and to use it correctly, to ensure the dog's comfort and safety.
Advantages of using a dog harness:
- Reduces pressure on the dog's neck and spine, which can prevent injury and neck pain. This is particularly beneficial for breeds with short snouts or breathing issues.
- Allows for better control over the dog during walks, as the harness distributes pressure evenly across the dog's body, making it more difficult for the dog to pull or escape.
- Provides an additional attachment point for a leash, such as on the dog's back, which can be useful for certain training exercises or for dogs that pull excessively.
Disadvantages of using a dog harness:
- Some dogs may find them uncomfortable or restrictive, and may resist wearing them.
- Harnesses can be more difficult to put on and take off than collars, which can be a problem for dogs that are particularly squirmy or anxious.
- Harness may not be suitable for all dogs, for example for dogs who have certain medical conditions such as hip dysplasia, a harness may not be the best option.
When it comes to a collar, it has its own benefits and disadvantages
Advantages of using a dog collar:
- Collars are simple to put on and take off, which can be convenient for dogs that are particularly squirmy or anxious.
- Collars are less restrictive than harnesses, which can be more comfortable for dogs that don't like the feeling of being constricted.
- Collars are more traditional and widely used, so many dog owners may feel more comfortable using them.
Disadvantages of using a dog collar:
- Collars can put pressure on the dog's neck and spine, which can cause injury or pain, especially if the dog pulls or is walked on a leash that is too tight.
- Collars are not as secure as harnesses, and dogs may be able to slip out of them more easily.
In conclusion, it's important to consider the individual needs and preferences of your dog when deciding whether to use a harness or a collar. A harness is generally considered to be a safer and more comfortable option for dogs, but some dogs may prefer a collar. It is always better to consult with a professional dog trainer or veterinarian before making a final decision.